I have been plugging motorcycle tires for 30 years and never had a plug fail so quickly that it put me in anymore danger than any other slow leak did that resulted in needing to plug in first place.
I bought a brand new K1200RS at the BMW dealer in Plano Tx back when BMW supplied a tire repair kit in the tool kit. On the way back home the day I picked it up, right about dark 30 I got a rear tire flat. I was fortunate to be close to a street light and had enough light to make repair, air it up with cO2 and get home. I rode that tire till it was worn out, bought a new one and the next day got ANOTHER screw in the new tire. Repaired and wore it out. I was convinced that brand new tires attract screws.
I bought a 12V 100 PSI High Volume Air Compressor from Harbor Freight for $30 and it works great but it weights 4.5 lbs and takes up too much space, so I am going for the CyclePump Lemke recomended.